CBRT rate cut sowing the seeds of next currency crisis
My subscription
...
Filters
My Subscription All Publications

CBRT rate cut sowing the seeds of next currency crisis

Turkey’s central bank stepped up its fight against economic orthodoxy by cutting its one-week repo rate by 100bp, to 13.00%, despite the backdrop of inflation at 80% and an extremely poor external position. This latest move could prove to be the trigger for yet another currency crisis.
  • Turkey’s central bank stepped up its fight against economic orthodoxy by cutting its one-week repo rate by 100bp, to 13.00%, despite the backdrop of inflation at 80% and an extremely poor external position. This latest move could prove to be the trigger for yet another currency crisis.
  • The decision was completely unexpected, with all of the analysts polled by Bloomberg anticipating that the CBRT would keep rates on hold for an eighth consecutive meeting. The accompanying statement said that the monetary policy committee expects the “disinflation process to start” and that there are signs of a “loss of momentum in economic activity”.
  • More than anything, it is clear that the CBRT is taking its instructions from President Erdogan, whose unorthodox views form the basis of the government’s “new economic model” of low real interest rates. After all, headline inflation stood at 79.6% y/y in July, the highest since 1998. (See Chart 1.) And Turkey’s external position remains extremely poor.
  • Concerns about the health of the global economy have increased this year but the fall in long-term US Treasury yields in recent months has supported an improvement in global risk appetite and probably made policymakers feel that they had sufficient cover to take action today.
  • That said, the move further increases the risk of yet another currency crisis. Prior to today’s decision, the authorities had tried to keep a tight grip on the lira at around 18/$. Turkey has been in similar situations in the past and we’ve always argued that such defences are, ultimately, futile. After all, Turkey is running a wide current account deficit (more than 5% of GDP in seasonally-adjusted terms in June), short-term external debts are large ($183bn) and foreign exchange reserves perilously low – net international reserves stand at just $15.7bn. In short, the CBRT is in no position to provide sustained support for the lira.
  • Admittedly, recent reports have suggested that Saudi Arabia may be about to deposit as much as $10bn in Turkey, possibly rising to as much as $20bn. But that support, if forthcoming, will merely act as a sticking plaster over a gaping wound. Even if the authorities managed to stage a defence of the lira in the near-term, without efforts to tackle high inflation that would simply lead to real exchange rate appreciation that erodes Turkey’s external competitiveness and causes external imbalances to mount.
  • The lira dropped 0.9% against the dollar following today’s decision, leaving it down by 26% year-to-date, and we think that it will fall a lot further to 24/$ (from 18.07/$ now) by the end of this year. (See Chart 2.) The risks are clearly skewed towards larger and more disorderly falls, which will become even more pertinent if the CBRT pursues further rate cuts. Indeed, we wouldn’t be surprised if the CBRT lowers interest rates further towards 10.00% by year-end.
  • Sharp falls in the lira pose a key threat to Turkey’s financial system given corporates’ large FX debts and banks’ high short-term external debts. What’s more, measures introduced at the height of last year’s currency crisis, including an the FX-linked deposit scheme, have started to intertwine currency, banking and sovereign risks. The upshot is that, if the CBRT is to pursue further rate cuts, we suspect that it will eventually have to resort to more restrictive capital controls.

Chart 1: Consumer Prices & One-week Repo Rate

Chart 2: Turkish Lira (vs. $, Inverted)

Sources: Refintiv, CEIC, Capital Economics

Sources: Refinitiv, CEIC, Capital Economics


Jason Tuvey, Senior Emerging Markets Economist, +44 (0)20 7808 4065, jason.tuvey@capitaleconomics.com

Jason Tuvey Senior Emerging Markets Economist
Continue reading

More from Emerging Europe

Emerging Europe Economics Update

Central and Eastern Europe GDP (Q2 2022)

A mixed performance, with Poland getting the wrong headlines GDP in Hungary and Romania continued to expand strongly in Q2 by 1-2% q/q, but the Czech and Slovakian economies barely grew at all and there was a shocking 2.3% q/q contraction in Poland. Looking ahead, the economic outlook has deteriorated sharply. External demand is weakening and inflation continues to surge.…

17 August 2022

Emerging Europe Data Response

Israel GDP (Q2 2022)

The stronger-than-expected 6.8% q/q annualised expansion in Israel GDP in Q2 confirms that the Q1 contraction was just a blip. Economic activity remains strong and alongside the red-hot inflation figures for July, the risks are skewed to a 75bp rate hike at next week’s central bank meeting. We think a 50bp hike (to 1.75%) is just about more likely but we maintain our view that rates will reach 3.0% next year. Europe Drop-In (18th Aug.): Winter is coming to the European economy – but how harsh will it get? Join this special briefing on the economic impact of Russia’s gas supply threat. Register now.

16 August 2022

Emerging Europe Data Response

Russia GDP (Q2 2022)

Russian GDP contracted by 4% y/y in Q2, consistent with a fall of 6% in seasonally-adjusted q/q terms – a much better performance than analysts had expected and than had seemed likely a few months ago. There have been signs of stabilisation in many sectors over the past month or two but we don’t expect the downturn to bottom out until Q2 2023 and think the economy will stagnate at best thereafter.

12 August 2022

More from Jason Tuvey

Middle East Economics Update

Egypt: Amer’s resignation raises scrutiny of pound policy

The resignation of Central Bank of Egypt (CBE) Governor Tarek Amer points to a growing tension within policymaking circles on the best way to address the country’s external imbalances. We think the next governor will ultimately need to let the pound fall further – our forecast is for the currency to fall to 25/$ by end-2024 (from 19.1/$ now) – and hike interest rates.

17 August 2022

Middle East Data Response

Saudi Arabia Consumer Prices (Jul.)

Saudi inflation picked up to 2.7% y/y in July due to strengthening underlying price pressures, but we think that it is now at or close to a peak and will gradually fall back over the rest of this year and next. If anything, the risks are skewed to the downside given the growing likelihood of a cut to the VAT rate.  

15 August 2022

Latin America Economics Update

Banxico to take its foot off the brakes

Mexico’s central bank (Banxico) hiked interest rates by 75bp, to 8.50%, for a second consecutive meeting yesterday but, amid mounting evidence that the economy is struggling and with inflation close to a peak, we think that the pace of tightening will slow from here. Our forecast is for the policy rate to reach 10.00% by year-end, which is a touch more hawkish than investors anticipate.

12 August 2022
↑ Back to top